Personal Injury Claims: Understanding Duty of Care, Negligence, and Contributory Negligence in Public Liability Cases

A discussion of Stephens v Minister of Police (21884/2017) [2025] ZAWCHC 72 (28 February 2025).

Introduction to Legal Principles

In personal injury cases, several legal principles come into play, including duty of care, negligence, and contributory negligence. The principle of duty of care requires entities to ensure that their premises are safe for public use. Negligence occurs when this duty is breached, resulting in harm. Contributory negligence arises when the injured party's actions contribute to their own harm.

Case Law: Stephens v Minister of Police

Facts of the Case

The case of Stephens v Minister of Police involved an 80-year-old man who fell from an unsecured landing at a police station. He had been directed by a police officer to wash his hands at a tap located outside. The plaintiff sustained injuries, including damage to his knee and facial lacerations. He claimed that the police officers failed to ensure the premises were safe for public use.

Court's Decision

The court found that the Minister of Police had a duty of care to ensure the safety of the premises. However, this duty was breached due to the absence of a railing and warning signs on the landing. Despite this, the court also determined that the plaintiff was 20% contributorily negligent for failing to look where he was going and not using the steps provided.

Key points from the court's decision include:

• Breach of Duty of Care: The absence of a railing and warning signs constituted negligence on the part of the defendant.
• Contributory Negligence: The plaintiff's failure to exercise caution and look where he was going contributed to his injuries.
• Apportionment of Liability: The Minister of Police was held liable for 80% of the plaintiff's damages, while the plaintiff was deemed 20% responsible.

Conclusion

The judgment in Stephens v Minister of Police highlights the importance of maintaining safe premises and the need for individuals to exercise reasonable care for their own safety. It emphasizes that entities must conduct thorough risk assessments and implement safety measures, while also considering the actions of the claimant when evaluating personal injury claims.