South African Citizenship Law: Court Rules in Favor of Stateless Child Born to Refugee Parents

A discussion of M.M.E and Others v Director General, Department of Home Affairs and Another (21970/2021) [2025] ZAGPPHC 202 (12 March 2025)

Introduction to Legal Principles

The South African legal system, particularly the South African Citizenship Act of 1995, outlines how citizenship is acquired. A key principle is that a child born in South Africa can become a citizen if one of their parents is a South African citizen at the time of birth. However, changes to the law have created complexities for children born to non-citizen parents. This article explores a recent court case involving a child born to refugee parents, highlighting the legal challenges and the court's decision to ensure the child's right to citizenship.

Legal Framework for Citizenship

• Citizenship by Birth: Before 2013, a child born in South Africa could become a citizen if one of their parents had permanent residence. After 2013, citizenship is granted if one parent is a South African citizen at the time of birth.
• Statelessness: The South African Citizenship Act aims to prevent statelessness by providing citizenship to children born in the country who do not have another nationality.
• Refugee Status: Refugees in South Africa face unique challenges in obtaining citizenship for their children, as they cannot easily access services from their country of origin without risking their refugee status.

Case Law: Facts and Court Decision

Background

The case involves a family of refugees from Rwanda living in South Africa. The parents, who are legally recognized refugees, have two daughters. The eldest daughter was born before the 2013 changes to the Citizenship Act and automatically became a South African citizen. However, the youngest daughter, born in 2015, did not qualify for automatic citizenship due to the new requirements.

The Challenge

• Statelessness: The youngest child was stateless because she did not qualify for South African citizenship and could not easily obtain Rwandan citizenship due to her parents' refugee status.
• Application for Citizenship: The parents applied for South African citizenship for their youngest child, but the application was refused by the Department of Home Affairs, citing that granting citizenship would be contrary to the Citizenship Act.

Court Decision

The High Court of South Africa reviewed the decision and ruled in favour of the applicants. The court declared the Department's refusal unlawful and ordered that the child be recognized as a South African citizen by birth under Section 2(2) of the Citizenship Act. This section ensures that a child born in South Africa who does not have the citizenship of any other country can become a South African citizen if their birth is registered in accordance with South African law.

Key Points of the Decision

• Prevention of Statelessness: The court emphasized the importance of preventing statelessness, especially for children, as it is constitutionally directed that every child should have a nationality from birth.
• Best Interests of the Child: The court prioritized the best interests of the child, noting that procedural technicalities should not override justice.
• Refugee Status Considerations: The court acknowledged the difficulties faced by refugees in accessing services from their country of origin, which would imperil their status and that of their family.

Conclusion

The court's decision highlights the importance of ensuring that children have a nationality from birth, as mandated by constitutional principles. It also underscores the challenges faced by refugee families in navigating citizenship laws. The ruling provides a significant precedent for similar cases, emphasizing the need to balance legal technicalities with the best interests of the child and the prevention of statelessness.